Homes for Sale in Shrewsbury, NJ

Shrewsbury is really two communities sharing one historic name. Shrewsbury Borough is one of the oldest settlements in the region — a designated historic district of tree-lined streets along the Broad Street/Route 35 corridor, minutes from downtown Red Bank. Shrewsbury Township is its small, quiet neighbor. Together they offer historic character, strong schools and a central Monmouth County location.

Living in Shrewsbury

  • Historic roots — among the oldest settlements in the region, with state and national historic district character in the Borough
  • Two towns, one name — the Borough and the Township are separate municipalities; this page covers both, and its listings button searches both
  • Schools — Borough students attend Shrewsbury Borough School (PreK–8), then Red Bank Regional High School; Township students attend the Tinton Falls School District (K–8), then Monmouth Regional High School
  • Location — the Route 35 corridor's shopping and dining, Red Bank's arts and restaurants next door, and Garden State Parkway access close by
Browse Live Shrewsbury Listings

Thinking of selling in Shrewsbury? Historic character and two strong school paths keep both Shrewsburys in steady demand. Get a free, no-pressure read on what yours is worth:

What's My Home Worth?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Shrewsbury Borough and Shrewsbury Township?

They are two separate municipalities. The Borough is the historic village center along Broad Street (Route 35); the Township is a small, quiet community nearby. This page covers both, and its listings button searches both.

What schools serve Shrewsbury?

In the Borough, Shrewsbury Borough School serves PreK–8 and students attend Red Bank Regional High School. In the Township, students attend the Tinton Falls School District for K–8 and Monmouth Regional High School for grades 9–12.

What is Shrewsbury, NJ known for?

Shrewsbury is known as one of the oldest settlements in the region, with a historic district in the Borough, tree-lined residential streets, and the Broad Street/Route 35 shopping and dining corridor — all right next door to Red Bank.

Who is a real estate agent in Shrewsbury, NJ?

Joe DiMaggio of Coldwell Banker Realty helps buyers and sellers in Shrewsbury Borough and Township and across New Jersey. Call him at (732) 551-1104, or get a free home value estimate on this site.

Buying or selling in Shrewsbury, work with an agent who knows these streets. Call Joe DiMaggio at (732) 551-1104.